Our partners and attorneys are highly qualified and highly experienced to advise you in all areas of Intellectual Property law. We advise start-ups, SMEs, and multinational corporations and ensure that your inventions, brands and designs are expertly protected.
EUIPO cancels MasterCard registrations: there are some things even MasterCard can’t buy
Home / News & Articles / EUIPO cancels MasterCard registrations: there are some things even MasterCard can’t buy
Trainee Trade Mark Attorney Anastasia Osipovich reports on the EUIPO’s cancellation of MasterCard’s registrations
The Cancellation Division of the EUIPO has recently declared the following two logo marks of
Mastercard International Incorporated (MasterCard) invalid:
Cancellation actions against these registrations were brought by Cinkciarz.pl Sp. z o.o., a Polish company offering online currency exchange services. Cinkciarz uses a logo depicting two interlocking circles – a black one and a white one – with the euro and dollar currency symbols in the centre:
Chikciarz argued that MasterCard’s marks are too banal and simple to be protected, and are therefore devoid of any distinctive character and should be kept free for other traders to use.
MasterCard’s arguments and evidence
To defend its rights MasterCard submitted a large volume of evidence in support of the argument that the marks are inherently distinctive and otherwise have acquired a distinctive character as a result of their use in the marketplace, therefore the marks should remain registered.
The company showed extensive figures relating to their market share, turnover and advertising expenditure. Moreover, the supporting evidence covered almost every country of the European Union and beyond. MasterCard illustrated its use of several different variations of their logo, particularly its well-known overlapping red and yellow circles.
Unfortunately for MasterCard, the EUIPO was not convinced by the evidence and found that it did not support the use of the marks as represented in either of the registrations in question. In fact, most of the provided examples of the use were considered to be irrelevant, or possibly even detrimental to the ultimate outcome of the case in this instance, as they referred to MasterCard’s other marks.
Deviation from Specsavers
MasterCard tried to rely on the famous Specsavers judgment, where CJEU decided that the average consumer could perceive the wordless logo as an indicator of origin when the use of the logo in conjunction with a word element did not affect the distinctive character of the wordless logo mark (SpecsaversInternational Healthcare Ltd & Ors v Asda StoresLtd  EWCA Civ 1294):
However, in the present scenario the EUIPO distinguished the facts from those of the Specsavers case holding that the evidence filed related to other MasterCard trade marks, of which the overlapping circles as registered will be merely seen as a component. According to the Cancellation Division the examples provided to by MasterCard stood too far from the representation of the trade marks on the register.
It should be borne in mind that a famous name, large revenue figures and piles of supporting evidence would not automatically guarantee a successful outcome when it comes to demonstrating genuine trade mark use. This EUIPO decision is an important reminder that the registrations aimed at a wider scope of protection for different variations of your brand may not always provide you with sufficient coverage. On the contrary, such marks can sometimes be especially vulnerable if these significantly deviate from the way your brand is actually being used in the course of trade.
The basics cookie, when enabled, means that we can save your preferences for the cookie settings panel and you won’t see the banner pop-up again unless you clear your browser’s cookie cache.
If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to interact with this panel again to enable or disable the cookies.
If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.
This website uses DoubleClick and Quancast to collect anonymous information such as the number of visitors to the site, and the most popular pages.
Keeping this cookie enabled helps us to improve our website.
Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!